Rashmi Guptey
1st February 2022
Harish Talreja
25th January 2022
Sid Talwar
31st December 2021
Ankit Moorjani
30th June 2021
20th January 2024
Sandeep Murthy
17th March 2022
1st January 2020
20th November 2017
7th June 2022
15th May 2022
17th February 2022
28th November 2023
Prashant Mehta
2nd February 2022
22nd September 2021
30th August 2021
15th March 2022
21st January 2022
14th January 2022
4th October 2024
5th August 2024
25th June 2024
20th December 2023
20th October 2021
25th April 2021
Akshat Jain
12th February 2021
31st May 2020
Tanya Rohatgi
19th August 2024
20th June 2024
Siddhant Ahuja
25th April 2022
14th February 2022
2nd June 2018
5th June 2024
15th February 2024
9th February 2024
26th May 2022
1st February 2024
20th November 2020
Shivani Daiya
20th February 2020
17th August 2014
18th July 2019
17th September 2021
15th September 2021
Maansi Vohra
28th January 2021
Atharva Purandare
10th January 2021
Tanvi Ghate
23rd January 2024
Ahan Rajgor
12th May 2022
8th March 2022
22nd February 2022
22nd August 2024
29th July 2024
5th June 2022
5th May 2022
16th April 2021
15th November 2014
25th October 2021
8th March 2020
7th August 2018
27th December 2016
17th February 2021
29th September 2020
24th September 2020
26th July 2020
20th January 2020
15th October 2018
26th June 2018
13th June 2017
21st May 2024
13th February 2024
15th July 2024
10th April 2024
20th February 2024
I respect the government’s desire to increase the tax net, curb black money, money laundering and build transparency in our tax system. What I don’t understand is why they make us a part of a guessing game with unheard of potential levies from time to time?
Here is why I say this:The biggest storm in the history of the Indian tax law has been the retrospective amendment to, inter alia, section 9(1)(i) of the Income-tax Act (i.e. the retrospective insertion of Explanations 4 & 5) by the Finance Act, 2012, seeking to tax in India, a transfer of shares of a foreign company deriving its value “substantially” from Indian assets, i.e. an indirect transfer of shares of an Indian company.
Thereafter, to clarify the applicability of this retrospective amendment, the Finance Act, 2015 made certain amendments including laying down of criteria for ‘substantial value’, providing for taxability of only income attributable to Indian assets and introducing a reporting requirement for underlying Indian entities. Valuation rules and clarifications were awaited on this front until May 2016 which meant some more guessing.
On May 23, 2016, CBDT released draft rules outlining the manner of computation in respect of the Underlying Indian Assets. FMV of such assets is to be Price determined by a merchant banker or an accountant in accordance with internationally accepted pricing methodology plus liabilities, if any. The manner of computation of the Target’s Total Assets has also been defined. I wonder why coming up with the rules regarding valuation took so long? Especially because valuation based on an “internationally accepted pricing” doesn’t not seem like a very novel or new approach to valuation!
Another such example is the Equalisation Levy of 6% that the Finance Act, 2016 (Act) introduced in respect of certain specified services involving payments exceeding INR 1,00,000 in the online marketing and advertising domain rendered by non-residents who do not have a permanent establishment (PE) in India. This is in the form of a withholding obligation. The draft rules have been notified very recently. What and who needs equalisation is still a question in my mind but this levy certainly means added administrative headache for an otherwise simple payout for an online marketing campaign or digital services.
The past week saw a string of articles stating that the Income tax department is in discussions to levy tax on start-ups that have seen a fall in valuations on the premise that the premium received by the company is their income. Section 56 has been in existence over 4-5 year now and largely impacts non SEBI registered domestic VCs and angel investors. We saw debates like “why should the tax department have a say in down valuations? “dip in valuations could be a pure business eventuality”, “there is lack of objectivity within the tax laws to defend the reasons behind a down round” etc...
Issues like definition of ‘royalty’, especially in the case of software (with respect to taxation and TDS), FPI related cases still being dug out for action by Income tax department cause a lot of heartache and uncertainty.So amidst running businesses, dealing with operational challenges, businesses are expected to guess the next tax move. I still have immense faith in the current government and our regulators and I am hopeful that we move to a more predictable tax regime with no room for the excessive creativity.
Uber, the popular Bangalore based cap operator was asked to change its payment mechanism by the Reserve Bank of India. Popular ecommerce sites like Myntra, Urban Ladder, Flipkart, and many other have been under the scanner for various regulatory matters like FDI violation, VAT related issues, Enforcement Directorate probes for maters before April 2013, Payment mechanism violations etc. With each passing day new violations or potential violations seem to be added.
The DIPP recently told the Delhi High Court that the marketplace model used by ecommerce companies is “not recognised” in the country’s foreign direct investment (FDI) policy and that the financial watchdogs are to investigate any violation.
India doesn’t lack funding, at least in technology. We need people – smart people, educated people, motivated people. Let’s teach coding. Let’s teach innovation and creativity. Let’s teach leadership and teamwork. And let’s make it free for anyone and everyone in the country.
We are technology investors, building new business models. This approach has served us well, but in the modern climate where technology is disrupting traditional industries.
You will receive the next newsletter in your inbox.
The monthly Gazette is your source of happenings within Lightbox - updates, blogs, deep dives, opinion pieces and all things consumer tech
Join the thousands who hear from us