30th March 2021
20th March 2020
13th March 2020
29th January 2019
17th November 2020
1st January 2020
20th November 2017
16th May 2017
16th February 2021
9th September 2020
3rd September 2020
22nd July 2020
31st March 2021
17th February 2021
7th December 2020
20th January 2020
26th April 2021
4th February 2021
30th May 2020
25th February 2020
25th April 2021
12th February 2021
31st May 2020
16th April 2019
1st June 2021
9th August 2020
26th March 2019
2nd June 2018
19th June 2020
13th December 2019
20th November 2020
20th February 2020
17th August 2014
18th July 2019
28th January 2021
10th January 2021
31st October 2020
15th November 2014
8th March 2020
7th August 2018
27th December 2016
4th May 2014
29th September 2020
24th September 2020
26th July 2020
12th June 2020
15th October 2018
26th June 2018
13th June 2017
4th January 2016
The pandemic has turned the way businesses function, and even how investors approach them. Sandeep, in a conversation with YourStory, speaks about the changes the ecosystem has seen over the last year and what investors expect from entrepreneurs.
YourStory (YS): How has the way you look at investments changed?
Sandeep Murthy (SM): It obviously has been a unique year, I think that the adjustments at the start of the year were significant. The lockdown started with the financial year, so the first two months were spent getting everyone’s house in order and coming to terms with the uncertainty. But you now realise that work has been going full steam for months now. Things adjusted, and today, we have new norms. It has made everyone focus on the essentials, and made us wonder – is it essential to be in the office every day, or to travel as much as we did? All this shifted and allowed people to explore and consider different ways of working and prioritising other parts of their lives. Companies across the board, and even at Lightbox, are taking our time to come back to the old ways of working. We aren’t excited to jump back into the old ways. We have found a way to get things working, such as initially meeting the investors virtually and then doing an in-person meeting later. What was essential about meeting in person was the ability to read the body language and the smaller nuances. Now we’ve found a new way of doing that. I believe that over time, things will revert. We'll get back to travelling, but it will still be a mix. What we now have is an acceptance that the newer method of doing things is okay.
Has it changed the way you look at companies and what you look for in startups?
SM: We had already started looking at the themes of sustainability and social good. Now, it has become even more important as the world is changing. It is incumbent upon us as investors to ensure that we're giving back in some way. We have started thinking that if the government is not going to have the resources, the wherewithal, or the focus to necessarily invest in the types of things that are going to ensure that we live in a better environment, I think that it's incumbent upon us and the companies we invest in to define how the consumption can take place going forward.
“We are investing in consumption and the future of a billion people. And if we ignore the present, we're going to leave the world in massive disarray. And if one billion people have a mindset of production that doesn’t care, then we leave behind a mess”
The idea is to focus on businesses that are mindful of their actions. For example, Bombay Shirt Company does custom clothing. The rationale is that fast fashion isn’t helping the environment. The wastage in terms of the number of clothes that end up in landfills, the notion that I'm going buy cheap product throw it away after a couple of uses, and then buy another one – it's just a terrible methodology.
The world has shifted and consumers have shifted into wanting to express themselves uniquely. There is a lot of awareness among consumers and they are demanding a shift. Today, for the consumer, buying a brand is representative of something. Also, consumers are caring about the kind of brands that care about the impact they have in the world. The outdoor gear brand – Patagonia, for example, has a simple premise - make the world a better place. They have a simple and unique way of operating their business.
“The idea of being good to society and the environment, as well as making a profit, are not mutually exclusive ideas. There needs to be a change in how we look at impact funding as opposed to for-profit funds. This idea was accelerated by the pandemic”
If you have a business model that works in the short term but has a massive potential impact in the long term, it becomes really important for us to think about that.
How do you find a balance between the two? What do you look for in the startups and the companies?
Lets put sustainability aside. When you’re looking at entrepreneurs and we're looking at opportunities, we're basically asking – is the kinesis enough? What I mean by that is, in the cycle of building a company, you're going to fail miserably as you go, and it's going to be challenging and can be difficult, so can you show me that you care enough about this problem as an opportunity that you're ready to stick it out. In all the things that you've done, is there any evidence or an underlying reason that clarifies why you're getting involved in this business, and which demonstrates that there you're in it – beyond the fact that it was just an opportunistic and a nice thing to do?
“We ask this question of everyone - what does success mean to you? And the question is not designed to look for any metric, but it tells you a lot when you start to hear the responses. Coming back to sustainability, it needs to be incorporated into the business model”
What about the founder’s personality? What do you look for in the founder?
Being a founder means being an interesting juxtaposition of the way you have to be. You have to be stubborn enough to not listen to people and go after what you're doing, and you also have to be self-aware enough to be able to invite people into building your business and managing their desires. This is true, especially in the early stages. When we started Cleartrip in the early days, everybody told us we were nuts. You will have to listen to everybody telling you that you’re an idiot, and still go after it. Then, you have to turn around and hire people, and tell them you want to incorporate their vision.
Its a Jekyll and Hyde kind of existence on a regular basis.
So you look for how people can do that. We have conversations that push them about why they're doing certain things, how they think it may not work, or share experiences about where it failed. And then you listen to whether or not they're willing to take that feedback where they have to listen. I think extreme self-awareness is required to be successful. But too much of it removes the drive. It comes to talking to people and seeing if you can make that relationship work. There are some relationships my partners can work with better than I can.
What advice would you like to give founders?
I read an interview that said: ‘don’t listen to your investors,’ and I think there is a bit of truth in that. You have to understand what everybody's motivations are and you have to be clear about what decisions you are making and why. Blindly following your own perspective, or blindly following your team's direction, or just listening to your investors is absolutely wrong. I think that it's important to assess individually what you think is the best decision to make by considering the different issues and then going about it. I think it's very easy to get attracted to the idea of growing fast as there's more capital available. Like, for example, in the book AI Superpowers by Kai-Fu Lee, Chinese entrepreneurs are described as mercenary, and US entrepreneurs as missionary. Unfortunately, Indian entrepreneurs are described as either having a huge ego or being media-driven. They're more interested in raising the most capital, and are not necessarily worried about winning in the game as a primary objective, nor are they worried about finding the best solutions. But, fortunately, that is shifting. More entrepreneurs are realising that things change, and that they can be aware.
So my advice would be to assess what's the right thing to do and look for certain businesses that have to get big really fast, otherwise you're probably not in a good place to contend.
But once you get hooked on this drug of raising tons of capital, you're dependent on one or two guys to supply that capital. And if there are not that many people to give the next $400-500 million cheque, you will run into some challenges to manage the burn.
Make the decision that feels right for the business not necessarily right for the external elements.
Source: YS interview
Look for an empty work station, a chair and get ready to go
That’s what Embibe taught me over the last four years, as an investor and advisor.
Four years and $100 million. Presented with those numbers, most venture capital firms would likely have spread their bets and racked up a bare minimum of a dozen investments. Not Lightbox. The VC firm has backed just six startups across its second fund raised in 2014 and a $54-million expansion vehicle set up two years later. Simply put, Lightbox does things its own way by banking on a light portfolio of consumer technology companies to build winners.
It’s really hard, but so powerful. The "hack" culture of Facebook or the "do no evil" approach of Google or the "respect everyone" culture of the Mahindras. It is amazing to see what great things can be accomplished when a founder drives core values effectively through an organization.
Pivots test your creativity, your persistency, your resiliency, your focus, your passion, and your grit in the best of times. A blitz pivot, especially to prove something to someone else, might be the best way to shut your company down.
Those that make it through are not unscathed – they have battle wounds. The challenges of the first year take their toll… emotionally, organizationally, culturally. While the first year has likely felt like a sprint, it is important to remember that this is a marathon and it is impossible to continue to run a marathon at a sprint pace.
What started off as a simple goal to make the world a better place has turned into a race to make it happen within a certain time. Once you are sure about that, take a deep breath and get ready to jump on the treadmill, because it will definitely be an exciting run.
We are at the cusp of creating great technology businesses in India. It can’t happen without the right support from a great board. And a great board needs independent directors.
Questions on the pitch process? You're in the right place
You will receive the next newsletter in your inbox.
The monthly Gazette is your source of happenings within Lightbox - updates, blogs, deep dives, opinion pieces and all things consumer tech
Join the thousands who hear from us